How can impact assessment practitioners apply culturally relevant GBA Plus to inform monitoring, evaluation, accountability, and learning (MEA&L) within impact assessment follow-up programs?
This FAQ draws on a GiiiA Network webinar on MEA&L presented by the Firelight Group.
Follow-up programs are a key component of impact assessment processes and support the ongoing management of environmental, health, social and economic effects identified during the assessment. Monitoring the effects of projects can be part of provincial and federal assessments.
Under the Impact Assessment Act (IAA), a follow-up program is defined as “a program for verifying the accuracy of the impact assessment of a designated project and determining the effectiveness of any mitigation measures.” In accordance with the IAA, the Minister establishes follow-up requirements and sets them out as legally binding conditions in the Decision Statement. Proponents are responsible for developing and implementing follow-up programs in compliance with those conditions, which may vary depending on the specific project and context. Follow up or monitoring activities may also be done in addition to those required through IA processes. For instance, they could be done as a result of consultation between communities and proponents and commitments made based on this.
Monitoring, Evaluation, Accountability, and Learning (MEA&L) is a project management framework used widely outside of impact assessments for considering whether projects are achieving their intended results. Within IA, the MEA&L framework can be used by proponents within their follow-up programs to help ensure that predicted effects and outcomes in impact assessments are tracked and that transparency, accountability, and learning are integrated into follow-up activities.
Key components of the MEA&L framework in IA follow-up programs
- Monitoring → Overseeing and tracking ongoing resource project activities and associated effects over time
- Evaluation → Assessing whether observed project effects align with those predicted in the impact assessment and whether mitigation measures are effective
- Accountability → Ensuring transparency and stakeholder trust through responsiveness to communities
- Learning → Adapting practices based on monitoring results, data, or feedback to improve project implementation and inform future impact assessments
Informing the MEA&L framework with culturally relevant GBA Plus considerations and applying this in follow-up programs can help ensure that monitoring accounts for biophysical and technical effects as well as environmental, health, social, and economic effects as they are experienced by diverse populations and communities. This approach also helps advance the knowledge and practice of impact assessments, in turn building trust and capacity among practitioners and affected communities.
ADDITIONAL DETAILS
Foundational features of culturally relevant GBA Plus-informed MEA&L
- Intersectional
- Culturally grounded
- Draws on mixed methods
- Is informed by Indigenous Knowledge
- Includes community-led governance
- Is flexible and adaptable to changing needs of communities
- Offers inclusive and safe spaces and approaches to ensure equitable participation
- Challenges assumptions, including the neutrality of impact assessments
- Recognizes how historical and structural factors may shape impact assessment processes and the experience of project effects
Using culturally relevant GBA Plus-informed MEA&L practices
Monitoring
Culturally relevant GBA Plus-informed monitoring requires identifying and using intersectional and culturally relevant indicators that account for the needs of diverse populations over time. They should be chosen with affected communities and include a variety of types of indicators, including the following:
- Structural indicators: measure policies, resources, capacity, and governance more broadly to provide context for specific projects; example indicators include
- Percentage of IA projects with Indigenous-led oversight committees, including representation from women, Elders, youth, 2SLGBTQIA+ peoples
- Budget allocated for Indigenous-led monitoring programs
- Process indicators: track implementation of project-specific activities; example indicators include
- Number of community engagement sessions disaggregated by gender, age, and identity groups. Who is leading these sessions? What is the quality of community engagement?
- Whether data collection protocols include culturally relevant disaggregation (e.g., by role, harvest, wage labour, language spoken)
- Outcome indicators: reflect changes in well-being, equity, access, safety, cultural continuity; example indicators include
- Percentage of community members reporting access to traditional harvesting areas post-project, by gender/age/identity group
- Rate of incidents related to community safety (e.g., gender-based violence, harassment) in project zones – monitored over time
- Level of satisfaction with engagement process (qualitative feedback) across diverse community groups
A variety of qualitative and quantitative intersectional data will be needed to establish a baseline and monitor indicators. Some intersectional data may already exist, for instance through Statistics Canada; however, there are significant gaps. Community-level data may need to be collected to carry out monitoring.
Mixed methods approaches that are appropriate for the data needs and communities should be used. For instance, quantitative methods may be used to collect data on food bank use, rates of violence, or use of specific services. Qualitative data can be gathered to understand changes in communities that are grounded in the experiences and knowledge systems of those affected and ideally collected by community members. Qualitative data collection strategies may include interviews, storytelling, etc.
Processes for storing, accessing, and using data should be developed in collaboration with communities to ensure that data are protected, and that communities have the authority to determine who can access it and under what conditions. [link to other FAQ].
Evaluation
Evaluation involves monitoring mitigation efforts and data to determine if the actual effects and outcomes match those predicted. Evaluation helps determine if the right indicators have been chosen, if mitigation measures are effective, and if any changes are needed.
It is critical for communities to be involved in interpreting data so that understanding effects is rooted in the lived experiences and knowledge systems of the affected populations. This helps make evaluations more accurate and reflective of how impacts manifest in particular contexts and for specific groups. It also captures how different communities define positive or negative outcomes, how they value environmental effects, and what they consider to be a significant impact.
Evaluations may be carried out on an ad hoc basis or at predetermined intervals, such as every six months, mid-project, and at the end of the project.
Accountability
Building accountability into follow-up programs will help build community and stakeholder trust by making sure that monitoring plans are followed appropriately. Incorporating feedback loops and accountability mechanisms through community-led governance and participation can help provide accountability. Community monitoring committees can be established and involved in multiple aspects of the follow-up program. Depending on the purpose and composition of the committee, it may be involved in designing and implementing the follow-up program, offering technical advice, facilitating community participation, and communicating information about the project and monitoring activities with the community (Noble, 2020). Monitoring committees can review follow-up programs and thus help ensure that they are implemented appropriately and that diverse interests aren’t overlooked.
Accountability measures also include establishing inclusive and safe spaces for equitable participation of diverse populations. This includes Indigenous communities as well as sub-groups within those communities, including women, girls, and Two Spirit folks. Consideration of barriers to participation should be accounted for and addressed. These could include offering different formats or locations for participation or offering childcare. For more details about ensuring equitable participation, see our FAQ on [include question we answer and link it here].
Accountability measures in follow-up programs should also include grievance mechanisms that communities can use to provide feedback and flag problems they experience. Grievance mechanisms can include formal complaint lines and other formal processes. However, capturing and taking seriously grievances identified through informal processes and relationships is also critical since fear or distrust of formal processes may lead to less participation.
Accountability should also reflect Indigenous ways of governing and making decisions, based on community laws, values, and protocols. These laws, values and protocols will vary since Indigenous groups are diverse. It is essential to recognize that accountability for one Indigenous community may look different from Western systems or other Indigenous communities. Ensuring that follow-up programs clearly define who is accountable, to whom, and how, according to each community’s expectations, is important.
Learning
Learning and adapting through follow-up programs can improve project-specific outcomes and lead to long-term improvements in IA processes. This requires flexibility in the follow-up programs, including responding to evaluation findings and adapting to the evolving needs of the community.
Community-based monitoring and evaluation contribute to a deeper and culturally-relevant understanding of effects, including why certain effects or unintended consequences occur. Using the results of community-based monitoring and evaluation to adapt monitoring processes going forward will support better long-term outcomes and reduce reliance on reactive responses in the future.
Learning can also occur over extended periods of time as indicators are tracked through follow-up programs. Monitoring long-term, cumulative, or unanticipated effects will build more complete understandings of how specific projects or types of projects function and how they can be better designed in the future as well as the effectiveness of specific mitigation measures. This information can inform and improve future impact assessments and methods.
Culturally relevant GBA Plus practices also highlight the importance of reflexivity in order to learn and adapt on an individual level. For more information about reflexive practices in IA, see… (link to reflexivity FAQ).
EXAMPLE
The following example arises from a provincial environmental assessment process and is provided for illustrative purposes.
The proponent of the Woodfibre LNG project proposed a change to the project to use a floatel (accommodations on a boat) to house project workers. One of the BC environmental assessment office’s (EAO) conditions of approval for this amendment was the development of a gender and cultural safety management plan. This is the first time the BC EAO has required this type of plan, but they will be required in the future for projects that involve work camps. The condition also required the formation of a gender safety advisory committee that includes Indigenous and non-Indigenous members from the project and community. The committee has helped in the development and implementation of several of the plan’s initiatives.
The gender and cultural safety management plan includes initiatives that work both toward preventing impacts and responding to those that arise. Key to prevention is a cultural awareness and gender safety training program that is mandatory for all Woodfibre staff, contractors, sub-contractors, and suppliers. These trainings are Indigenous-led and cover areas such as bias and stereotypes, risks for Indigenous women and girls, historical context, and intersectionality. Additional mandatory training covers bullying and harassment, violence, and harassment prevention. Initiatives also include processes to respond to issues that do arise, including confidential reporting and mental health, sexual health, and addictions services.
Monitoring will be done in part by collecting data for a number of indicators, such as complaints made through the confidential reporting line, incidents of violence or harassment, the use of mental health services, warnings or suspensions based on breaking the code of conduct, work days missed by demographic, number of workers who quit by demographic, and number/type of incident reports (such as sexual assault or cultural violence). The gender and cultural safety advisory committee will play a role in updating this list when necessary as well as monitoring them over time. Community level monitoring of gendered effects of the project will also be done through existing regular community engagement led by Sḵwxw̱ú7mesh Úxwumixw (Squamish Nation) to identify the project’s adverse effects. Monitoring will also be aided by a four-year project gathering regional data about gender-based violence and harassment during the construction phase of the project.
Citations and useful resources
- Gender-Based Analysis Plus in Impact Assessment. Government of Canada, (2024, June 21). https://www.canada.ca/en/impact-assessment-agency/services/policy-guidance/gender-based-analysis-plus-impact-assessment-fact-sheet.html
- Impact assessment process. Government of Canada. (2025b, June 5). https://www.canada.ca/en/impact-assessment-agency/programs/impact-assessments-101/impact-assessment-process.html
- International Indigenous Women’s Forum. (2020, August). “Empowerment of Indigenous Women through Co-Investment. Cycles 2009–2019. A Contribution to Intercultural Philanthropy.”
- MacKay, C., James, B., Audet, P., & Setterington, M. (2024). (tech.). How are follow-up programs implemented in Canada? International Association for Impact Assessment. https://2024.iaia.org/presentations/696_mackay_how_are_followup_programs.pdf
- Noble BF. 2020. Follow-up and monitoring in impact assessment: Synthesis of knowledge and practice. Technical research report prepared for the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada. Ottawa, ON. 76p
- Online course, Indigenous Evaluation in the Context of Truth and Reconciliation, Hotıì ts’eeda, Reciprocal Consulting, and the Canadian Evaluation Society, Fall 2022.
- Woodfibre LNG. Gender and Cultural Safety Plan Woodfibre LNG Project. https://projects.eao.gov.bc.ca/api/public/document/6644e69624b6ce0022ff52b9/download/Woodfibre%20LNG%20Gender%20and%20Cultural%20Safety%20Plan%20v8%20May13%20final%20clean.pdf.
- Firelight Group PowerPoint Presentation, Incorporating GBA Plus into the MEA&L Framework (link to come)